The Corbett’s are they harder than the Munro’s? What are your favourite ones?

Corbetts are Scottish mountains over 2,500 feet (762 metres) and under 3,000 feet (914.4 metres), with a drop of a least 500 feet (152 metres) between each listed hill and any adjacent higher one.

There are 222 summits classified as Corbetts, and they are named after John Rooke Corbett, who originally listed them. Corbett joined the Scottish Mountaineering Club in 1923 and, in 1930, became the fourth person, and first Englishman, to complete the Munros.

Those who climb all 222 peaks are termed Corbetteers. John Rooke Corbett was the first person known to have climbed all the 2,500 foot peaks on his list. However in contrast to the numbers completing the Munros, the total number of people who have registered as completing the Corbetts is only in the hundreds. Completions are recorded with the Scottish Mountaineering Club.

To me it took many years to appreciate them. I think it was just being daft and influenced by others as you are at the time.

As I near my completion there is still no rush I have learned so much since my first Corbett in Arran on Goatfell aged 4.

Since I started mountaineering I was chasing Munro’s, rock and ice climbing and taking part in Expeditions all over the world yet over the years the Corbett’s have given me so much enjoyment.

To me they are still like the Munro’s were in my early days pathless and you did not meet many folk. Many are still pathless and take a lot of effort and are impressive mountains in any weather.

It’s amazing how many of my pals who are now on the mission to climb them. Many are experienced Mountaineers yet many say these Corbett’s can be and are harder than the Munro’s ?

I must admit I have been amazed by them. I thought I knew Scotland but the Corbett’s really open your eyes to the mountains. You visited different areas see different things from there summits and ridges.

Despite doing the Munro’s and tops several times and 4 traverses of Scotland the views from some Corbett’s are unsurpassed.

You see the Munro’s from another angle and the huge Glens and parts of this wild country that you missed in the past.

I loved my trips to the Islands Rum,Jura and Clisham on Harris. Add into this the wonders of exploring places like Ardgour and it’s hard won Summits.

I was so lucky to climb a few by boat in my days with the RAF Rescue team. Fun trips to Rum and other Islands made the journey so memorable.

We had a few Corbetters in the RAF Kinloss Team and we had a ditty as some of us thought in these days they were easy hills. A easy day out how wrong we were.

“Big fat belly’s and loads of beer.

We are the Kinloss Corbetter’s “

My apologises to all.

Now I understand after 60 years how daft were we. I look back on my trips to wild areas like Knoydart , Fisherfield and so many others than involve a big hard days. Bikes were also used a lot with a few miles of pushing at times but on the way back home it was fun.

I have memories of camping high on Beinn Lair and other hills after 4 months on Everest I was so happy back home on my hills. I have also done a fair few Corbett’s from far flung bothies. This all adds to the mystery and allure of these hills.

Yet some are ideal for a short day when travelling and lots of journeys in the car have been broken by a quick Corbett. Feeling refreshed after even a short day on the hill when travelling South to England. Hills like Ben Vrackie near Pitlochry, the Sow of Atholl and Morrone near Braemar. They all help make a short day out there are many more.

Some are ideal for taking kids on like my local Corbett Ben Rinnes there are many more for an introduction to the hills. Recovering from an illness or after bad news many of these hills were a great comfort. Many I climbed on my own ( always leaving a note) A few shocked me with the navigation in poor weather especially in winter. Some of the summits can be scrambled to or climbed on recognises routes that few apart from the Cobbler will you meet anyone. I climbed Fionaven always by a rock climb in the 70’s over 6 ascents in the remote Coire and always did the full ridge carrying all my gear.

There are memories of the great Galloway hills with their magical names that also allured me as a boy. Big walks with big bags on my Duke of Edinburgh Award.

I try to climb them nowadays in good weather to get the view. Nowadays there is no rush , no time limit for me especially in the summer. I want to see the view look back into my memory and when out on these hills I feel alive and young after a long trudge to a summit.

These hills have been so good to me and given me so much.

We have to look after them treat them with respect and watch nature all around us. I now see Windfarms and Estate roads even from the remote summits a sign of progress?

I have not mentioned Assynt and it’s incredible peaks with the lochs, the sea and the mountains a special place to me.

Some of my favourite hills in no order:

The Cobbler

Beinn Lair

Cir Mhor

Ben Aden

Streap.

Quinag

Fionaven

Quinag

Beinn Damh

There are many other hills in the book many are not Corbett’s but show you some of Scotland’s great mountains. They maybe small in stature but big in heart.

This is the words I love about these hills.

“Glaciers, grinding West, gouged out
these valleys, rasping the brown sandstone,
and left, on the hard rock below –
the ruffled foreland –
this frieze of mountains, filed
on the blue air –
Stac Polly,

Cul Beag, Cul Mor, Suilven,
Canisp –
a frieze and
a litany.

Extract from “A Man in Assynt” Norman MacCaig.

These books below will open your eyes to these magical hills. Hamish Brown to me is a genius his books are a Bible to me. He has inspired me with so many interesting facts about the history and culture of these unique mountains. I never tire of reading it.

CliClimbing the Corbetts  Scotland’s 2500ft Summits

HaHamish Brown

Hamish Brown portrait

Hamish Brown is a legendary climber, walker, traveller and author. He is the author and editor of many books, including Tom Weir, an anthology of work selected from throughout the great man’s life…

A great read.

Review from Walk Highlands

In 2009 fell-runner, Manny Gorman set out to complete a continuous traverse of the Scottish Corbetts on foot, bike and sail. At the time the run was followed avidly by many on Walkhighlands and the riveting read he has produced distills the epic 70 day challenge into a very readable book that will appeal to anyone interested in the Scottish hills or crazy human endeavours.

A cracking read well worth it. Manny book is an inspiring read.

Description

The author details the 222 Corbetts which exist in Scotland. These hills between 2500 and 2999 feet high are amongst the most popular and accessible since they are often a good afternoon’s exercise as opposed to the generally more testing and trying Munros which are frequently situated in more extreme terrain. 

As always comments welcome. Here are some :

Al Barnyard

Great piece Heavy. Suilven and Fuar Tholl hold particular significance to me as they were both pivotal hill days that assisted in health recovery.🙂

Andy Lawson

Favourites include: Beinn Dearg Mor, Quinag, Foinaven, Ben Loyal, Beinn Damh, Baosbheinn, Cir Mhor, Beinn an Lochain, Ben Aden, Fuar Tholl.

Erick Brunskill

“good luck on your corbett round Heavy, I decided to do all 3 categories at the same time and the rough pathless nature of the corbetts and grahams and lack of opportunity to do multi summit days make them hard. But in the winter I guess the Munros are usually harder. due to the higher altitude and higher likelihood of snow wading and more technical winter challenges and dangers”

Robin Clothier

David Whalley. “You need to do the Corbett tops”

Anne Butler – guru of all things hilly !!

“Yes…….and then there’s the Grahams🤔”

Robin Clothier they have been rebranded as Simms now………Corbett Tops are no more.”

David Whalley geeky nerd more like.🙄

http://www.rhb.org.uk/simms/

About heavywhalley.MBE

Mountain Rescue Specialist. Environmentalist. Spent 37 years with RAF Mountain Rescue and 3 years with a civilian Team . Still an active Mountaineer when body slows, loves the wild places.
This entry was posted in Book, Books, Bothies, Corbetts, Corbetts and other hills, Enviroment, Friends, Hill running and huge days!, Mountain rescue, Mountaineering, Munros, Other hills Grahams & Donalds, Recomended books and Guides, Sailing trips, Views Mountaineering, Weather. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to The Corbett’s are they harder than the Munro’s? What are your favourite ones?

  1. Susan B says:

    Need to review that last sentence, Heavy

    Like

  2. Ged Murray says:

    Dave

    I am sure when at NMSU on my second tour Joe Mitchell was into his Corbetts.

    In your story the other week to Pakistan, did Joe and young Fletch also go in your trip there.

    My best memory of Fletch was when both on NMSU two team fuel tanks.
    Took a telephone call on our desk to tell Cpl Fletcher a Sea King was coming in to take him to Aberdeen Airport to catch a flight south to rescue soldiers lost in Borneo/ Malaysia on expedition.

    The best thing is he never believed me as he thought I was trying to take the mick out of him until the telephone went again asking why he was not over at the MRS.

    Eventually team leader Chief Technician Brian Williams had to tell him to get his ar*e over to MRS as the Sea King was due to pick them up.

    Remember when he got back, we laughed over a cup of tea that I was trying to set him up for a laugh.

    He did say the rescue cost thousands and some of the Army guys made it out of the gully.

    We both ended up at Leuchars when the NMSU contract was handed over to FRA Serco Fletch to full time MRS and myself to the Hydraulic Bay.

    Seen him again on my last tour at Leuchars in 2006 when he was visiting as a civilian to guys I worked with MRS guys in AMF.

    John a small weegie guy an avionics tech.a fellow CT who was also into caving also an MRT team leader I think. Not often I forget his surname you may help me and Simon Brill , Paul Millen, Martin Chadwick and Sqn Ldr Paul Lipscomb.

    Have a great memories of working with the guys Joe Mitchell was a brilliant rigger.

    Liked by 1 person

    • The Caver was Ian Rolland sadly killed in a cave in Mexico
      “IAN DROWNED.” In a cave 4,500 feet beneath Oaxaca, Mexico, with an underground waterfall roaring in the background, Bill Stone didn’t hear those words as much as he sensed them. He knew that the odds of survival at close to a mile deep aren’t great for even the strongest cavers, a chiseled superset of explorers who routinely haul 180-pound loads down 65-foot vertical shafts, live for weeks underground, and dive through bone-chilling water. Mapping the last uncharted land on earth is a dangerous proposition. One slip, one momentary lapse of concentration, and you die.

      At the time of his death, Ian Rolland had been using Stone’s latest invention – the Mk-IV, a device now referred to as a rebreather, which scrubs exhaled air and recirculates it, greatly extending the amount of time a diver can stay underwater. Still experimental when Rolland strapped it on, the Mk-IV had the potential to push cave exploration to ever greater depths. Each unit had triple redundancies and was debugged in countless simulations, but the Oaxaca expedition was the real thing. When Rolland’s body was found at the far end of a flooded, 1,400-foot-long cavern, the natural assumption was that the innovative equipment had somehow failed.

      There was only one way to find out: Someone would have to retrieve the body and the equipment, in all a 300-pound load. With his team leery of the new technology and exhausted after a dozen days underground, Stone knew it was up to him. He’d have to traverse the sump himself, and carry Rolland back through a stalactite-riddled black pool of near-freezing water, breathing the recycled air being pumped into his lungs by his own contraption. And hope to hell that whatever happened to Rolland didn’t likewise happen to him.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.