USAF Voodoo aircraft crash – Meall Odhar Ardgour May 1964 – 50 years on.

I was asked to check out an aircraft crash that occurred 50 years ago in the remote West Coast of Scotland.  This was an American aircraft a Voodoo F -101 and involved a huge search on the West Coast of Scotland. This is a big incident in the history of the RAF Mountain Rescue and the search was a huge event at the time. This was the Cold War and much of the story was kept under wraps!

Originally, the  Voodoo F-101 was intended as a long range escort fighter for the B-36 bombers.McDonnell F-101 Voodoos were operated by the USAF and later by the RCAF. At the time of the accident, the F-101C Voodoo featured here was on a training flight from its base at RAF Bentwaters in Suffolk, England.  However, while flying over the Scottish highlands at 28,000ft as part of a 3 ship sortie the fighter 56-0013 exploded in mid-air. This was according to the other aircraft apparently without warning. The pilot had no opportunity to eject from his stricken aircraft.  Wreckage from the fighter-bomber was strewn over a wide area in the vicinity of Maol Odhar (Creach Bheinn) in the Ardgour area of the Scottish Highlands, about 15 miles SW of Fort William. An extensive search was conducted by the USAF, RAF and mountain rescue teams. However, the crash site was not discovered until 10 days later.

This was a  massive search that involved  no less than eight Hercules aircraft from Prestwick; eight HC-54s (Skymasters), and eight C-47 (Skytrain / Dakotas), together with other aircraft and ground search teams. It was a huge search. As usual  the Press reports speculated that live ammunition or nuclear bombs / warheads had exploded causing the crash.

The airman who died in this accident was:

  • Capt. Morris H Reed (28). Pilot.
F - 101 Voodoo

F – 101 Voodoo

This was before my time but my friend Ray Sefton/ John Hinde was involved in the search  planning. The search was 9 days long 7 May – 16 May. RAF Kinloss/ Leuchars/Leeming/ Valley/St Athan were involved Glencoe & Lochaber Mountain Rescue Teams and Coastguards . This must have been a huge search to get the Southern RAF Mountain Rescue Teams up to assist, the pressure on the teams must have been immense! John Hindes report states: All mountain ridges and summits in allocated areas searched heavy mist and poor cloud base most days. Weather hail, rain but some summits clear.  John mentions there was lack of direction from the search controllers for the first 2 days. Local reports meant the teams searched areas like Glenfinnan but it was another aircraft at a similar time. Eventually sightings and reports of a bang in the Loch Linne area and updates from the lead pilot of the sortie tied in with local reports. The aircraft was spotted by a USAF C47 on the 15 May. Next day RAF Kinloss located the aircraft after a search of Meall Odhar, the point of impact was at 2500  feet less than 30 feet below the corrie rim on very steep loose ground. The impact had made the area pretty dangerous and recovery would be a difficult and hazardous task”  The USAF  recovered the wreckage and remains and there is plenty of wreckage still within the area, much of it in the Corrie Floor below.  One of the comments was the teams need more binoculars there were only issued with 3 per team! Binoculars are still a great Search tool today! 

Voodoo Crash site

Voodoo Crash site

This wreck site is quite remote and little known, and the story deserves to be told. It lies in the hills of the Morvern peninsula on the west coast. The Voodoo jet fighter crashed near the 794m summit of Maol Odhar, about 1km east of Creach Bheinn. The wreck site is unusual in being a relatively recent military aircraft crash site that has never been cleared. I bet there  are a few stories connected with this Search and recovery?  

I hope to visit these hills soon and pay my respects!

Footnote  In 2005  – On Ardgour, Erik Brunskill and Gavin Macfie added Voodoo Buttress (V,6) on Maol Odhar. Erik described this as one of his best days out in Scotland ever, praise indeed!

About heavywhalley.MBE

Mountain Rescue Specialist. Environmentalist. Spent 37 years with RAF Mountain Rescue and 3 years with a civilian Team . Still an active Mountaineer when body slows, loves the wild places.
This entry was posted in Aircraft incidents, Articles, Corbetts, History, Mountain rescue, Mountaineering, Scottish winter climbing.. Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to USAF Voodoo aircraft crash – Meall Odhar Ardgour May 1964 – 50 years on.

  1. Dave Earl says:

    Some more details with pics and news clippings on Alan Clark`s website Dave.

    Like

  2. Ray Sefton says:

    You told the story well. What started the search in the Glen Finnan area was a report of a jet belching flame and smoke disappearing into cloud on a hill adjacent to Loch Shiel. It took 3 days for a scimitar pilot to admit he was beating up the Glen Finnan viaduct.
    My lasting memory of this call out was the absolute squalor that the troops lived in and still maintained their morale. Apart from the first night in the old shed the rest of the bases were in tents. We had little kit and usually stood astride the “bomb” (Hydra Burner) tunnel, until we were dry. On call outs, we were always on compo rations for the first three days and then went onto fresh rations, if we were lucky. Because, this operation was of national importance our support from Pitreavie RCC, after the first day, was exceptional.
    The bonus in Glencoe was that big Ingrid, the wife of the Youth Hostel Warden, made us very welcome and dried out as much kit as she could. (This huge lady became a friend of the team over many years and it was not unknown for her to crash out in the ATC hut in Fort William, much to the consternation of the newer troops.)

    Like

  3. Ian Thornber, the Morven stalker, tells me that he found a twisted silver coin at the site as they recovered the body, and that he always regretted not having had the presence of mind at the time to send it to the young man’s mother.

    Like

  4. Ian Williams says:

    I have been researching the logs of the lifeboat based at Mallaig at this time ‘E E M GORDON CUBBIN’ and the following is from her log regarding this incident:
    8th May -LB launched to help in search for USAF aircraft believed crashed in west of Loch Linnhe; Coll Tyree, thence to Iona and directed to search west coast of Mull
    USAF aircraft were also searching the area, but no contact could be made after repeated calls on VHF radio using call sign given by Southend CG via Oban Radio. No trace found and directed back to base.
    9th May – On request from Southend CG LB launched to continue search for missing USAF aircraft with instructions to search all Lochs and inlets as far south as far as possible including Loch Sunart.
    Searched as far south as Ardnamurchan Point then to Tobermory to refuel and rest for the night as instructed by Hon. Sec.
    10 May – Left Tobermory next morning and searched Loch Sunart. No sign of missing aircraft. Continued search round Ardnamurchan Point when message was received to proceed 5 mls NE of Ardnamurchan Point to investigate 2 puffs of smoke reported. LB position at this time was only 3 mls away.
    Area searched thoroughly by LB; passing tanker and small coaster assisted by aircraft. LB communicated with aircraft with good reception, but no sign of missing aircraft found.
    LB was then instructed to search shoreward’s to Rudha Carrach – no trace of aircraft found. LB then instructed to return to base.

    Hope this adds to the picture.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Rob Graham says:

    Now this is very curious as I have always kept a logbook of my climbing, which I am confidant is accurate. On the weekend – a holiday one I am assuming as we were away for 4 days – of May 1964, 8 to 11th, I was initially climbing in Glen Coe and then the party moved to Ardgour to climb the Great Ridge of Ardgour in good weather conditions. On the 10th, according to my records we were on the summit of Garbh Bheinn late in the afternoon / early evening “.. watching a ‘copter hovering over Creach Beinn where they had finally found the missing US plane.” My logbook in those days was always written up with a lot of detail of the routes and typically was done as part of that evening’s tasks so the date discrepancy from the seeming official reports leaves me with a puzzle.
    One of the things that lead me to explore this further is that the 1:50000 map of the area shows ‘Camp’ near the summit of Creach Beinn – and Google Earth shows what looks like the foundations of a shed.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Bernie Goodman says:

    There appears to be some confusion between the name of the peak. In your story you name the location as Maol Odhar (Creach Bheinn), but you also list Meall Odhar as the crash site. According to Google Maps, these are different peaks and not necessarily close to each other. Other documents and authors also mix the two peaks up in regarding the crash site of F-101 56-0013. Maol Odhar is the correct peak.

    Liked by 1 person

    • McDonnell F-101C Voodoo 56-0013 of 81st Tactical Fighter Wing, 78th Tactical Fighter Squadron, crashed near the summit of the 794-metre high Maol Odhar in Western Scotland, approximately 15 miles from Fort William on 7th May 1964 whilst on a training flight from RAF Bentwaters in Suffolk
      I have visited the site several times

      Like

      • Robert Graham says:

        It is possible that I have made this comment before as I have a record
        of this event from my climbing logbook.

        I was brought up by my climbing mentor, Hamish Brown, to always keep a
        logbook, and have a comment against this particular May holiday weekend
        (“May weekend 8,9,10,11: 1964”) that is interesting in terms of dates.

        I was in a party that went to Ardgour to climb on Garbh Bheinn. Partly
        because the party wasn’t all that strong it took us till 17.30 to get to
        the top via what I have recorded as ‘The Great Ridge’ on the 10th May. 
        What is a slight puzzle is that my logbook  then records “.. and we then
        meandered over to Sron a Gharbh () to
        watch the ‘copter hovering over Creach Beinn where they had finally
        found the missing American plane”.

        I’m assuming that I wrote up that log which is pretty detailed about the
        climbing (and my falling off at one point!!) within a day or so, but it
        would seem that we were seeing something that conflicts with the date of
        15th May in Heavywhalley’s posting of 16th May 2013.

        As a coincidence I have a slightly younger climbing friend who was at
        the primary school in Fort William then, and his memory is of the
        authorities taking over the school playground for the helicopters, etc. 
        I guess not much teaching was absorbed for that week!

        Rob Graham

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.